As I browse board game-related social media, I find a lot of people have similar problems when deciding what their next board game should be. Mage Knight vs Runebound is one of those common questions. Both fantasy themed adventures (or so it seems), but when you look underneath, there are several differences that will make them appeal to different audiences.
This article explores similarities, differences and tells you which one is better for you – providing you know what kind of a player you are.
Mage Knight Facts
Year published: 2018
Number of players: 1-5, best with 1.
Playing time: 120-240 minutes per set-up.
Suggested player age: 14+
Complexity rating (according to BGG): 4.57/5
Average rating (according to BGG): 9/10
- Puzzle-solving deck-builder, wrapped in a fantasy world.
- One of the best solo experiences in the board game world.
- Playing it requires a lot of effort and time investment.
- Mage Knight Base Game
- The Lost Legion Expansion
- Dual Color Cards Expansion
- Krang Character Expansion
- Shades of Tezla Expansion
- Mage Knight Ultimate Edition
Mage Knight has received plenty of expansions: adding new characters, scenarios, enemies, and more. If you are looking to dive into the world of Mage Knight, there is only one way to go – Mage Knight Ultimate Edition. It contains all the expansions listed above, has some revised rules, and is a lot more cost-effective than buying items one by one.
As for playing it, I’d suggest starting with the elements of the base game and add expansion elements (new heroes, terrain tiles, enemy tokens, action cards, spells, artifacts, and units) slowly, one at a time.
Runebound (3rd Edition) Facts
Year published: 2004 (1st Edition), 2005 (2nd Edition), 2015 (3rd Edition)
Number of players: 2-4, best with 2.
Playing time: 2-3 hours
Suggested player age: 12+
Complexity rating (according to BGG): 2.66/5
Average rating (according to BGG): 7.5/10
- A streamlined, polished latest iteration in the Runebound series.
- A good mixture of exploration, adventure, and combat.
- Just the right amount of “random factor”: movement dice, combat tokens, and card drafting.
- Runebound (Third Edition): The Mountains Rise – Adventure Pack (2016)
- Runebound (Third Edition): The Gilded Blade – Adventure Pack (2016)
- Runebound (Third Edition): Fall of the Dark Star – Scenario Pack (2016)
- Runebound (Third Edition): Caught in a Web – Scenario Pack (2016)
- Runebound (Third Edition): Unbreakable Bonds (2017)
The base game comes with two scenarios. With all the variables, it offers some replayability, but sooner or later you’ll start looking for more scenarios. Both offer a whole new narrative experience and are a very recommended add-on. As are adventure packs, which add new adventure cards, enemies, events, quests, and skills.
Unbreakable Bonds is a larger expansion with new game mechanics, introducing co-op and solo modes, accompanied by 2 new scenarios along with events, cards, and quests. It makes an already good game even better and is a must, especially if you want to play solo.
As there are no compilations available, I suggest you start out with the base game and then add expansions one by one, based on your desires.
Both games follow unwritten fantasy “rules”: You are a hero who travels a fantasy world, explores interesting sites, interacts with locals, and combats all sorts of fantasy beasts (including dragons, of course).
In this process, you learn new skills and abilities, acquire new gear and other special items to prepare for the final boss fight (i.e. Margat the Dragonlord in Runebound or General Volkare in Mage Knight).
Both Runebound and Mage Knight are quite an investment when it comes to money. While the base game of Runebound is cheaper than Mage Knight Ultimate Edition, when you start to add expansions, it quickly surpasses it.
Fixed map vs modular map
While both games’ terrain is hex-based, this is where similarities end. In Mage Knight, the map will be different every time and there is a true sense of exploration as you never know what lies on the next tile.
In Runebound, exploration lies in hidden quest tokens – the cards you draw are different every time. The map is always the same, but it has a lot more character and landmarks, while in Mage Knight it’s a bit soulless.
Mage Knight uses movement cards that are a part of your deck. You know there is a finite amount of them in there per round, so you must use them wisely and don’t stray off your path too much or you will lose momentum. Random factor comes from the draw – sometimes you will have less or more in your hand than what you need and you must then improvise.
Runebound’s heroes use their speed characteristics to determine how many movement dice they can roll at once. The dice have terrain types pictured on sides and you can only move on the rolled terrain. You can use all of your three actions to move, meaning you can traverse 9 tiles per turn if your hero has 3 speed (you roll three dice). So, even if you don’t roll favorably, you are not too much hindered.
Mage Knight’s combat is a math problem. You have your enemies on one side (with their attack, armor, and other stats known) and your hand cards on the other. It’s up to you to find the optimal solution to the problem (how to kill the monster without disposing of too much health or valuable cards) and normally a mathematically best course of action can be found.
Runebound features a significant luck component, although it’s somewhat weighted. For each combat, a number of two-sided tokens are cast for both the hero and the enemy. The number and type of tokens depending on the characteristics and strength of participants. As you gain new gear, you will also gain a corresponding token, making you immediately more potent in combat.
The fight is resolved by playing out the tokens in turns, trying to find the best combination of attacks, blocking the enemy, and other abilities. The enemy tokens are played by the player on your right.
A mentality difference is that in the Runebound you can be more reckless in combat, going with hunches and trying to gamble it out with tokens. In Mage Knight, there is no luck to save you. You have to know exactly what you are doing, if the fight can be won or not or what is the price of victory before you engage. (Note: There are few occasions of hidden enemies to spice things up.)
We could sum up:
- Mage Knight is more deterministic, while Runebound leaves some room for Lady Luck.
- This makes Mage Knight prone to analysis-paralysis, which is bad for non-solo play. Runebound runs much smoother because players don’t have all the information and must act on gut feeling often.
- Runebound is more focused on theme and story, while MK shines for its brilliant mechanics. The former feels more like an RPG game where you can lean back and enjoy, while MK is an exercise in optimization and it’s hard work.
You play the games with completely different mindsets.
- If you like the surprise element: not knowing where you’ll be able to move, what is going to happen in the encounter spot, or how you will do in a fight.
- If you prefer theme and narrative over mechanics and like a lighter game.
- If you don’t like games with a lot of rules scattered over several hefty rule books.
Why Mage Knight?
- If you like to plan your turn and make meaningful decisions pretty much every turn.
- If you look for a top solo player experience.
- If you care more for solid mechanics than for theme.
Mage Knight vs Runebound – Conclusion
Hopefully, your dilemma is solved.
While Runebound is definitely not a light game (I’d rate it medium complex) it’s better suited for players who just want to have a good time, without having to put in too much effort. It rewards players with a great story-driven adventure, full of quests, choices, combat, and character progression.
Mage Knight, on the other hand, is the real deal. It’s meant for dedicated board gamers, not afraid of a hundred tiny rules and intricate game mechanics. What it gives back is impressive: it rewards you for solving problems in exploration, travel, interaction, and combat, wrapped in a deck-building progression system.
I know what kind of player I am – and if you are not new to my site, you probably know which path I went down. What about you, what kind of person are you?
- Mage Knight vs Gloomhaven
- Tips for Mage Knight’s Solo Conquest scenario
- Is Mage Knight Ultimate Edition Worth it?
- Similar games:
If you have any questions or a comment, feel free to leave them in the section below.