There are some board games, that can be played after only a couple of minutes of explanation, making them ideal when introducing new players to board gaming. Small World is one of those gateway games, although it has some complicated bits. Read my Small World Board Game Review to learn what those are.
Introduction to Small World Board Game Review
BoardGameGeek home page
Players: 2-5, plays well with all numbers
Playing time: 40-80 minutes, depending on player count.
Complexity: a simple, good gateway board game.
My score: 7.5/10
The world is too small for all of us
Primarily a war game, in Small World, you will control a race with special powers, looking for their space in a colorful fantasy world. You’ll fight other races, other players and, when you feel your race is starting to lose its power, you can choose a new one and continue the fight with them.
The game is not about building civilizations, but about conquering regions and scoring points immediately after each of your turns. Control of regions will move from one player to the other in a matter of turns. Do try to defend them, but don’t get too attached to them.
Choose your race
There are two double-sided game boards included in the base game, with separate maps for 2, 3, 4, or 5 player games. This ensures the game is well-balanced for all player counts, although the sweet spot is around 3 to 4 players. Maps come with all sorts of features: mines, mountains, hills, farmlands, lakes, forests, underworld, swamps, magic, etc., each giving bonuses to races or abilities.
Your most important decision(s) you will make in Small World, is choosing a race and a special power. There are six random combinations of race and special powers available at any time – the top one is free, for others you must pay coins. You must consider offered abilities carefully, taking into account other players and the situation on the map.
Some of the available 14 races are:
- Dwarves get an extra coin for each mine region.
- Ghouls can stay on the map after a decline and you can play them as if they were active. You’re controlling two races now.
- Giants conquer regions, adjacent to mountains for one less token.
- Humans get an extra coin for each farmland region.
And so on with Amazons, Elves, Halflings, Orcs, Ratmen, Skeletons, Sorcerors, Tritons, Trolls and Wizards, you get the picture.
20 Special powers include:
- Alchemist gets 2 coins after each turn
- Bivouacking can place encampments, that count as tokens when defending.
- Commando lets you conquer a region with one less token.
- Diplomat lets you make peace with another player (you’re immune to his attacks).
- Flying allows you to conquer any region on the map (no need to be adjacent).
- Forest gets extra coin for each forest region.
- Heroic allows you to place 2 heroes, that make regions immune to conquer.
Others are Berserk, Dragon Master, Fortified, Hill, Merchant, Mounted, Pillaging, Seafaring, Spirit, Stout, Swamp, Underworld, and Wealthy.
You can do the exact maths, but there are a lot of combinations available. And, if that is not enough, there are expansions available that add more races and special powers.
It’s worth mentioning that the box insert comes with spaces for tokens for all of those races, all in separate boxes, so making them ready for a game is a piece of cake. The components are of high quality.
How to play
Small World is limited by turns (8-10), which depends on the number of players. Each turn, you will have several race tokens available. This depends on your race, your special ability, and is reduced each time one of your regions gets conquered.
You will use those tokens to conquer other territories. These can be empty, occupied by the Ancient tribe, or by other races. Combat is a simple have-more-tokens-than-the-defender, although you must take into consideration all of your and defender’s special powers. This can be slightly confusing and can take some time, especially when you’re still learning the game.
When using your final token(s) to conquer, you may be a couple of tokens short – you can overcome this with a roll of the die. But don’t count on it, because half of the die is empty. Now you have the option to redeploy – move your tokens around to defend some of your more valuable regions.
After that, it’s time for scoring. You get a coin for each region you control with your races (both in decline and active), plus you get bonuses for your active race (if any apply).
Other players will try to conquer as well, and as regions are conquered, defending tokens get removed from the game one by one. In practice, this means, that a race is only good for 3 or 4 turns. After that, you won’t have many tokens left to continue your conquests. Elves don’t lose tokens this way, so you could play the entire game with only them.
Decline your race
Now is a good time to put your race into decline. You remove all but one token from each region and flip them over. You will still get points for those controlled regions – until someone conquers them, of course – but, you won’t be able to control a declined race anymore (except Ghouls, they’re special).
Next turn you get to choose another race/ability combo from the offer and the whole process repeats. I find that you will on average go through 3 races in a game. Choosing a combo and choosing where on the map to make your initial conquest is what wins or loses the game.
Coins are collected after each turn and players keep them hidden until the end of the game. With observation, you can estimate how much money players have and can adjust your strategy accordingly (i.e. who to attack).
What I think about Small World
I find Small World a very good combination of simplicity and diversity. Simplicity comes from placing tokens and solving combat, while different races and abilities provide the diversifying factor, making every game different.
There is a tactical element to it: which regions to capture, where to reinforce your defense, which player to focus on; and a very strong strategic element: when to go into decline and choosing your race/ability combo. It takes experience and situational analysis to figure out which combo is best suited for the current situation.
Novice players often make the mistake of clinging to their races for too long and not going into decline. When you have 4 or fewer tokens available to conquer, it’s usually best to declare a decline.
Everyone attacks everyone
One of the negative things about the game is, that the games are very close. How is that bad, you ask? If anyone plays really well and goes into a lead, other players will start to pick on him, equalizing the field. It means it’s not predominantly skill that wins games, but rather how left-alone one gets to be.
I find the sweet spot to be a 3 or 4 player game. In a two-player game, it’s hard to come back after an initial setback. An initial setback is easy to inflict if you start second – just pick a race that will do the most damage to your opponent, after he’s already played his turn.
Five player game suffers slightly from downtime. There’s not much to do between turns (other than help other players calculate tokens and coins). It’s better when players get to know the races and special powers a bit more, but starting out, all the calculations take some time. A Six-player board is available as an expansion, but it’s hard to find in stores.
Don’t take too personally when you are attacked (because that’s what the game is about), rather try to have some fun and good laughs (because that’s what the game is about). In such games, I like to derive my pleasure in making good moves and playing optimally. If that brings me victory, fine – if not, that’s fine too.
One tactic that I feel works nicely is to play defensively – reinforce you crucial regions, making them as costly as possible to attack, then use your diplomatic abilities (trash talking) to divert player towards other targets.
All this comes with simple rules and a great-looking fantasy theme, making it very visually appealing. It’s a great gateway game – once you take into account all the abilities, it’s good for the more advanced players as well – but after a while, you will wish for more strategic options.
Besides the tabletop version, the game is also available on Steam. Price is for the base game, expansions can be bought separately.
- 2, 3, 4, and 5 player maps available, with all the races and abilities of the base game.
- Good and transparent user interface. All the important information is displayed, race and ability details can be accessed easily.
- Capable bots.
- Depopulated multiplayer.
- Good for practicing different combos.
- Fun to play, but doesn’t reach the tabletop version.
- Doesn’t have the diplomacy mini-game that usually happens around the table.
The Digital edition of Small World is worth a buy, but I would recommend getting it on a sale.
Conclusion and recommendation
Small World is a good game, especially for players who are new to board gaming and have only played the likes of Risk. It offers decent strategic and tactical options, set in a beautiful fantasy world, full of diverse races. Despite the high number, they are well-balanced.
Decline mechanic is unique too, as are multiple game boards. No player elimination is another positive.
More complex alternatives
Although a more advanced player can still have a lot of fun with the game, sooner or later he will desire that there would be more that he could do. More options to emphasize his skill, instead of equalizing it.
If you’re looking for something similar to Risk, but more advanced, Small World is a great choice. However, for more advanced players, I’d suggest taking a look at games like 1775: Rebellion or War of the Ring.
Or for something slightly different, but still accessible, check out Charterstone, a legacy worker-placement game.
Small World is worth a purchase
Still, Small World is a good game and I give it a thumbs up. I recommend buying the re-skinned Underground edition since the original is very hard to find in stores.
If you have any questions about Small World, post them in the comments below.