Settlers of Catan – Board Game Review

I’m pretty sure everyone with a remote interest in board gaming has heard of Catan by now, if not played it. It has achieved legendary status in the last 25 years. But, since then, many board games have surpassed it, both mechanically and commercially. Read this Settlers of Catan Review to find out whether it still holds its own. Is it worth playing after all these years?

Introduction to Catan

Catan was designed by Klaus Teuber and originally published in Germany in 1995. The game became hugely successful and popular, got translated into multiple languages, and sold millions of copies worldwide. It was one of the first eurogames that hit the global market and made its way into mainstream entertainment. Suddenly, everyone was playing it.

What Is A Gateway Board Game? + 10 Examples

After the original release, various extensions and expansion packs (together with reprints) have been released (and still are). For now, we will focus just on the base game.

Players: 3 or 4
Playing time: 1 to 2 hours (depends on players)
Ages: 10+
Game complexity: light-medium
BordGameGeek page: link.

Theme and Concept of Catan

The players assume roles of settlers, who are trying to settle on an island, which produces various resources. These resources can then be traded and used to build additional settlements, roads, or buy development cards.

The theme is very similar to a video game called Settlers (also from the mid 90’s), which was also made by a German studio BlueByte and enjoyed success worldwide. I guess there is something appealing about colonizing virgin lands and claiming them as yours. And having the word settlers in the title obviously also helps. (Although Catan has ditched the word settlers in recent years.)

Your settlements, roads, and armies count for victory points. The goal of the game is to accumulate ten or more victory points – the first player to do so is the winner.

At its core Settlers of Catan is an abstract strategy game with elements of set-collecting and resource management. Its secret is, that the theme is well-thought-out and works brilliantly hand-in-hand with the concept.

settlers of catan board

 

Seting up a game of Catan

Game preparation begins with the laying of hexagonal terrain tiles (18 resource tiles + 1 desert tile) and surrounding water tiles. These can be arranged randomly, although there are suggestions in the game manual for a fixed arrangement which should give players equal opportunities.

Next, it’s time to give resource tiles number tokens from 2 to 12 (excluding 7). Numbers 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, 10, and 11 are represented twice, while numbers 2 and 12 are represented once – a total of 18 numbers. Again, there is a suggested pattern for numbers – or you can just go all out random.

Number tokens represent the probability of a tile producing a resource in a turn. This is determined by throwing two dice and the sum of the throws is a number from 2 to 12. As a general guideline 7 is a result with the highest probability and further away from 7, the rarer the throw will be.

Initial settlement placement happens next. Players place two villages each, with one road next to it. They do this in a predetermined order as not to give anyone an advantage: player 1, player 2, player 3, player 4, player 4, player 3, player 2, player 1. Each places 1 village at a time.

It’s all pretty easy and straightforward. After a couple of games, you’ll be setting up games with blind eyes almost.

If you would like to avoid setting up the game altogether, you can do this by playing Settlers of Catan online for free – check the review of Asobrain platform.

Gameplay

When players receive their starting resources based on their initial villages, the game can start. On each player’s turn, there is a dice roll. The resulting number determines which tile(s) will yield resources. Each village on the edge of such tile receives one resource and each city receives two resource cards. There are five different resources.

There is no hard cap on how many resources a player can hold in its hand, however, when a 7 is thrown, each player with 8 or more resource cards must discard half of the cards.

Settlers of catan resources

The player in turn then has options on what to do with his resources. He can spend them on building villages, upgrading villages into cities, building roads, or buying development cards.

A player also has an option to trade them. He can trade with the bank at a rate of 4:1 (4 same resources for one he needs), 3:1 if he has a settlement on a 3:1 port, or even 2:1 if he has a settlement on a special port slot. Another option to trade is with other players. Here only player’s diplomatic skills determine, what one can bargain.

If a player buys a development card, the card is drawn from a special tile. These can contain:

  • invention cards (special ability cards, like an option to build two roads for free, draw 2 resources for free or play a resource monopoly – drawing specific resource cards from other players),
  • outright victory points or
  • knights.

Development cards can be played at any time inside a player’s turn.

Highway Robbery

When a 7 is thrown, no resources are given out. Instead, a player has to move a black meeple, a robber (at the game start, the robber is placed in the desert), to a resource tile of his choosing. That tile is then blocked from producing resources until the robber is moved somewhere else.

Moreover, if there are settlements on the adjacent tiles, the player who moved the robber, can rob one of the other players (who has a settlement on the edge of that tile) of a random resource card (draw one from the opponent’s hand). settlers of catan robber

Playing a knight card is basically the same as throwing a 7 – it gives a player a chance to move the robber (hopefully to one of the opponents’ tiles).

When a player has played 3 or more knight cards, he receives an achievement card called the Largest Army, which is worth 2 victory points. This card is transferred to another player if he fields a larger army.

How is Catan won?

The goal of Settlers of Catan is to be the first to accumulate 10 victory points.

  • A village is worth 1 point,
  • a city 2 points,
  • longest continuing road 2 points and
  • the largest army also 2 points.
  • On top of that, there are victory points received from development cards.

Victory is usually achieved after 1-2 hours of gameplay, depending on the player count and their experience. More experienced players will complete their turns faster and the game will progress more smoothly.

If you hate losing at Catan, then check this article: Tips and Tricks for winning.

Luck in Settlers of Catan

There are two ways random factor plays a role in Catan. One is the initial tile placement and the second is the dice throws each turn. The first factor is the same for everyone, while the second tends to even out somehow as there are many dice throws in a game.

Dice can play quite a role in Catan, infusing a lot of excitement, but also frustration. Although there are numbers with a higher probability, it’s often more practical to have your settlements on as many different numbers as possible, just to ensure a steady flow of resources.

This part is also why so many people have a love/hate relationship with Catan. People tend not to understand how probability works and how to adapt their strategies. They blame all their bad play on dice. But with a proper understanding of game mechanics, one can embrace this element and treat it as part of the game.

Skill and Diplomacy

There are a lot of options the player has in a game to demonstrate his prowess. It starts with initial settlement placement which is by far the most important decision. It hugely impacts how the rest of the game will be played out and what strategies a player will (and can) employ. Social skills also play a great role, since there is much to gain by trading.

Expansion for Settlers of Catan

Read about the most common Settlers of Catan expansions in the following articles:

But these two are only the tip of the iceberg. There are numerous adaptations, extensions, and stand-alone games base on Catan (like the one based on Star Trek or Games of Thrones). It has become a big brand and the owners are aware of that.

The complete list is too long for this review, but you can find it on Wikipedia.

settlers of catan city

Conclusion

Settlers of Catan is still, after all these years, a good board game. It’s strong on the market, expansions and editions keep pouring in, and if you haven’t tried the classic yet, now is an as good time as any.

It’s still among the Top 10 Most Popular Board Games

But this article is only the tip of an iceberg, there are many more aspects that we haven’t covered here: initial settlement placement studies, general game strategies and tactics, different editions and expansions, and much more. A lot of those are covered in other articles (you’ve seen links to them already), so go ahead and check them out.

If you found this overview useful, have any questions or comments, please leave them below. Any feedback is immensely appreciated.

Vasilij

Settlers of Catan

3.85

Theme and components

3.8/5

Game mechanics

3.8/5

Longevity

4.1/5

Pros

  • Modern classic
  • Easy-to-learn mechanics
  • Big family of expansions

Cons

  • Dependant on dice
  • Can't be played with 2
  • Many games have surpassed it mechanically

10 thoughts on “Settlers of Catan – Board Game Review”

  1. Looks like a really fun game. Thanks for the summary rather than just writing the instructions 😀 Do you have a favourite game?

    Reply
  2. This is such a new game concept. I never thought games like these would actually be put on game boards especially since I have seen some many like the Simpsons being just online.

    I did not see the pros and cons or these games. What are they? do you know?

    Reply
    • It’s 24 years old already. You would be amazed about all the things that have been made into board games.

      Pro’s and con’s of Catan. Maybe i’ll make n post on this topic, but to be brief:
      + great theme and presentation,
      + easy to learn but engaging game mechanics,
      + fun to trade with your friends,
      + luck doesn’t play a big role,
      – not a lot to do when it’s not your turn,
      – in later stages the wait time can get long,
      – can’t be played by 2 players, 3 is minimum.

      Reply
  3. WOW, thank you so Vasilij. This is a game that i enjoy seeing people playing it but i have never had a deep knowledge as your post has gotten me more enlightened. Startiung laying the hexagonal terain tiles, giving resource tiles numbers down to Initial settlement placement.
    So, elaborate that i feel playing right away.
    thank you for such a wonderful post.

    Reply
  4. Hi Vasilij,

    I really enjoyed reading your review of settlers of catan. It sounds like a great game and definitely one to put on my Christmas list. I would also like to check out your recommendation of Scythe. Do you have a review of this game as well as it sounds really good? Thanks in advance, Andrew

    Reply
  5. Thank you so much for this informative introduction to Settlers of Catan and review. I’ve been told that a family member really loves the game so I’m hoping to find something for him for the holidays that would be a good addition to his game. He’s already a pretty avid player, so I think the expansion packs you mention might bring a new level of excitement for his games. Thanks for helping me to understand the language — hopefully the next time I see him he will teach me how to play!

    Reply
    • I reviewed the main expansion packs: Seafarers and Cities & Knigths already, but try to feel him out a bit , he might already have them. Maybe Traders & Barbarians or Explorers & Pirates would interest him, they are a bit rarer.

      I have not reviewed them (yet), but they were well received by other critics, so I would recommend them.

      Reply

Leave a Comment

Our website uses cookies to provide the best experience for the user.

Acknowledged!

 

Win a copy of Everdell!

Victory Conditions Giveaways Homepage